Piston Tanks - proportional control

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • David F
    SubCommittee Member
    • Jan 2016
    • 60

    #1

    Piston Tanks - proportional control

    If you are interested in developing or building proportional piston tanks, I am pleased to give some details here:





    A basic description of the controller follows:

    - Proportional means that a stick movement produces a proportional movement of the piston in the tank.

    The electronics to proportionally control a piston tank needs to have the following functions:
    - A method of counting the revolutions of the screw thread which drives the tank. (A Hall effect sensor, in this case.)

    - A microprocessor (In this case a PIC) to process the receiver output and remember the number of screw thread revolutions and to control the motor control board (The H bridge.) The software includes proportional and derivative control functions. The counter can be reset by powering off the TX. The software includes lost signal routines.

    - The H bridge is a driver chip and 4 MOSFET transistors which control the piston tank drive motor in forward and reverse. The H bridge is to a Microchip design and includes the protection suggested by John R (Electrolytic capacitors fed by Schottky diodes to prevent any problems with current surges.)

    -Limit switches are needed to provide security against any drive overruns. I favour a completely independent circuit using microswitches with diodes to allow reverse. (See Norbert Bruggen's schematics in "Model Submarine Technology) In normal operation only one microswitch is triggered and this only on first power up.

    The design is very reliable and I have used this every 2 weeks or so in one of my 3 submarines for the last 4 years with 3 different tanks. I have used it with both 40Mhz and 433/458 Mhz r/c equipment as developed by Tim Senecal. It works with both but the lack of interference on 433/458 makes the piston tank work more smoothly.

    The software is made available under an open license for people to use and modify as they wish on the basis that their software continues to be available to others. So it is not for commercial gain.

    The software is written in assembler for a PIC micro.

    An Arduino version written in C would be very welcome!

    The mechanical construction of piston tanks is covered elsewhere in the AMS Forum but some tips include:

    - threaded M5 stainless rod works well and matches the "screw turn data" from the controller.

    - don't try to move the piston too quickly - current draw and electrical surge problems. I use gearbox ratios of about 1:30.

    - the magnets for Hall effect sensors have a habit of flying off and sticking to steel items! They can be attached to suitable gear wheels etc using hot melt adhesive.

    Have fun with the design and I hope you find it useful and please say how you have used it and suggest (and make public) any software improvements.

    David Forrest
  • IdefixRC
    Junior Member
    • Apr 2017
    • 42

    #2
    Hi David,

    good stuff. Thanks.
    I'm planning to build a arduino based controller (probably not proportional though) for my current project.
    Will post the code in the forum here once I'm successful (if there is such a basic, end stop based code out there already, happy to hear about it).

    cheers,
    Eric

    Comment

    • Ivcarlo
      Junior Member
      • Mar 2018
      • 11

      #3
      Hi David,
      i am newby in the forum and in the rc submarines realm.
      I would like to figure out if i can build on myself the piston tank system before to choose a submarine model.
      Please can you tell me some reference for the mechanical construction of the tank? So if i can find the list of necessary materials maybe i figure out what Scale to choose for my sub model.

      Thank you very much.
      Ivan

      Comment

      • salmon
        Treasurer
        • Jul 2011
        • 2342

        #4
        Ivan welcome! If I may, building a piston first is backwards. It would like buying tires for a car when you have not purchased a car yet. See what I am saying?
        Why? The piston is used to make the sub buoyant and lift a portion of its superstructure out of the water. Not just solely make it raise and lower in the water. A research sub has very little above the surface, so smaller piston is needed, but a WWII sub like the Type VII or Gato have a LOT to lift out of the water and will have larger ballast tanks.

        To size a piston tank, you will need to know how much volume you will need to give your sub proper surface trim. That being said, here is a thread on making a piston if you just want to play and learn how to make a piston:
        Can you help me figure out how to build a piston tank? what or how do you make a spindle nut? and how does this connect to the motor? I notice that it is used


        Norbert Bruggen wrote a book on Submarine technology if you want to go deeper into the ways to figure out how large you need.
        Peace,
        Tom
        Last edited by salmon; 04-04-2018, 06:45 PM.
        If you can cut, drill, saw, hit things and swear a lot, you're well on the way to building a working model sub.

        Comment

        • Ivcarlo
          Junior Member
          • Mar 2018
          • 11

          #5
          Hi Tom,
          thank you! I am very grateful for any advice because i have no experience.

          Your right about to buy tyres before the car. For now i am only trying to get a general view of the matter.
          Some days ago i read the pdf of Steve Neill about hull building and then i have so many questions about the diving system.
          I would love to build a piston thank system much more than a WTC with gas iniection system. And i will look forward to know if i can build it by myself.

          I looked around the forum and saw so many thread with your messages... I think you are very expert! :-)
          Can i go with other questions?

          For now i would like to build the Alfa class or the Akula, but as soon as i saw it i fell in love with the Typhoon.
          You are trying to say me that i may choose the design or the scale i like without thinking to diving system?
          Finally when i have the hull i will start to evaluate internal volume and buoyant of the model? I think it will be necessary to calculate with math the air and liquid volumes and it scares me a lot. Maybe it's impossible to go by trials...

          I found two different versions about the Norbert Bruggen's book at about 30-40$
          Do you think it is a good investment for a beginner?

          Thank so much,
          Ivan

          Comment

          • thor
            SubCommittee Member
            • Feb 2009
            • 1479

            #6
            Norbert Bruggens book is not for beginners. If you have a degree in electrical engineering, it makes an excellent reference.
            Regards,

            Matt

            Comment

            • JWLaRue
              Managing Editor, SubCommittee Report
              • Aug 1994
              • 4281

              #7
              Originally posted by Ivcarlo View Post
              You are trying to say me that i may choose the design or the scale i like without thinking to diving system?

              Finally when i have the hull i will start to evaluate internal volume and buoyant of the model? I think it will be necessary to calculate with math the air and liquid volumes and it scares me a lot. Maybe it's impossible to go by trials...

              I found two different versions about the Norbert Bruggen's book at about 30-40$
              Do you think it is a good investment for a beginner?
              Ivan,

              Except in rare instances, it is not absolutely necessary to decide what kind of ballast system to use when selecting the type of sub or the size of the sub. The exception is mostly if you are looking at a very small sub with limited internal volume for the dive module. Sometimes there is so little room inside that the choice of ballast system may be restricted. The larger the size of the sub, the easier it is to fit whatever ballast system / dive module into the hull.

              It doesn't hurt to consider both the type and size of the sub while also deciding on the ballast system....but I would say that it is not absolutely required.

              I think your question about the "internal volume and the buoyancy" of the model really comes down to how does one figure out how much moveable ballast (i.e.: water) does the ballast tank need to handle to both surface and submerge the boat. Generally people are buying pre-made ballast systems and get one that the manufacturer indicates will be large enough to work. We also ask for advice from other R/C sub modelers. Either way you can determine the size of the ballast tank without relying on math. You can also do this by doing a test trim of the boat at both the surfaced and submerged waterlines and noting how much additional foam is required to go from submerged to surface condition. I've helped a couple of friends do this and it's only taken about 15-20 minutes to do this. You do not need a dive module or ballast tank to do this...just some weights and foam.

              Norbert's books provide a lot of very good information. Just be careful with his circuit diagrams, I've been told that there are inaccuracies in some of them.

              Keep asking questions, we're here to help!

              -Jeff
              Rohr 1.....Los!

              Comment

              • Ivcarlo
                Junior Member
                • Mar 2018
                • 11

                #8
                Thanks Jeff,
                much much clear!
                I will have some days to process mentally the informations ... and the new questions ;-)
                Anyway i am not in hurry and this project will not start soon.

                I think i will get the Norbert book, i am not an engineer, i am only graduate in electronics but i am familiar with technical books and i like very much to undestand thoroughly subjects that i like.

                You live mostly in the beautiful United States (unfortunately i still could not come but i have wanted it for years) but i found a very good Italian forum. And there's a great explanation about how to calculate ratio between hull stability and gravity center...


                Maybe i will find some people to meet near home. I will ask...

                Bye for now!
                Thanks a lot!
                Ivan

                P.S.
                I have joined to the SubCommittee with a year of electronic issues.
                Please can you help me to know when will be release of the SubCommittee Report?

                Comment

                • salmon
                  Treasurer
                  • Jul 2011
                  • 2342

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Ivcarlo View Post
                  Hi Tom,
                  I looked around the forum and saw so many thread with your messages... I think you are very expert! :-)
                  Can i go with other questions?

                  For now i would like to build the Alfa class or the Akula, but as soon as i saw it i fell in love with the Typhoon.

                  Ivan
                  Ivan,
                  Me an expert? I hardly think so.....Active in posting and sharing absolutely. Gaining knowledge, yes! There are gentlemen on this site that have been in this hobby for decades and may not post much, but are willing to help if you get stuck. You will find others share what they know and if anyone is not accurate others will correct. Ultimately, we all want you to have a successful build and join the ranks of those that sail.

                  Not all subs are good candidate for piston (because of size, weight, or shape). Some subs do better with a different ballast system. You are considering Alpha, Akula, or Typhoon. Great submarines! Are you planning on buying a hull or make it yourself?
                  If buying, before doing so, share with the group what one you have selected and probably others will have built that sub. We can also help with figuring out what you need in ballast volume.
                  If you can cut, drill, saw, hit things and swear a lot, you're well on the way to building a working model sub.

                  Comment

                  • salmon
                    Treasurer
                    • Jul 2011
                    • 2342

                    #10
                    Originally posted by thor View Post
                    Norbert Bruggens book is not for beginners. If you have a degree in electrical engineering, it makes an excellent reference.

                    What a relief to hear Matt, my brain hurts every time I read it. It is not all electrical and as Jeff pointed out there are some errors in the electrical diagrams - for that matter electronics as a whole have gotten smaller and, I think, better. The other chapters on ballast and hull design are really good to learn from. Is it a beginner's book? It depends on the person. I read it as a beginner and learned a lot. I also did not understand a lot.
                    If you can cut, drill, saw, hit things and swear a lot, you're well on the way to building a working model sub.

                    Comment

                    • JWLaRue
                      Managing Editor, SubCommittee Report
                      • Aug 1994
                      • 4281

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Ivcarlo View Post
                      Please can you help me to know when will be release of the SubCommittee Report?
                      Ivan,

                      The SubCommittee Report is published 4 times a year: March, June, September and December. We strive to publish on the first of the month.

                      I hope you have found that all of our back issues are online for members to download. We also have a full index of all articles to aid in finding content.

                      -Jeff
                      Rohr 1.....Los!

                      Comment

                      • Ivcarlo
                        Junior Member
                        • Mar 2018
                        • 11

                        #12
                        I thought of the fateful question about buying a fully working model or build a totally DIY model.
                        I would be oriented towards a model fully built by myself. For simple reasons. It is much more satisafactory and then in my life i would love to learn as many things as possible even at cost of many frustrations.
                        It will be possible? I suppose yes. Then if i only have sailing pleasure i lost half the taste. Like for the holidays, maybe the journey is part of the whole.

                        For now i only can study the subject matter because i have no money to start the project.
                        Then i have a baby 14 months old and have no much freetime.
                        But i started to think something to share with him. Something of manual ability to teach him to hold the welder in his hand.
                        :-)

                        My favourite candidate will be the Typhhon, i love it. But maybe it will be a little too much challenging as the first submarine?
                        As i said i have no troubles with bang my head over it and if it will take a long time. But i need something really challenging otherwise after a while I lose interest.
                        Then i don't want to put on money and work hours in costruction of simple subs only to become familiar with. I would like to learn while doing.
                        This is my point of view.
                        But maybe i could be too pretentious... It is possible that I do not realize it because i am a newbie.
                        In this case i could switch towards Alfa or Akula.
                        Then the Typhoon may be too bigger and difficult to store and to carry out.
                        Plese can you give me some of your thoughts about that?

                        Question about sailing. Is it inadvisable to put sub in the sea? For RC waves distribution or other?
                        I ask it because i live near the sea and not near lakes.

                        Thanks for every help.

                        Comment

                        • Ivcarlo
                          Junior Member
                          • Mar 2018
                          • 11

                          #13
                          Originally posted by JWLaRue View Post
                          Ivan,

                          The SubCommittee Report is published 4 times a year: March, June, September and December. We strive to publish on the first of the month.

                          I hope you have found that all of our back issues are online for members to download. We also have a full index of all articles to aid in finding content.

                          -Jeff
                          FANTASTIC i didn't know it.
                          I tried to search myself because i wanted to get there alone without asking... But i don' find where.
                          Please help!
                          Where i can download those?

                          Comment

                          • salmon
                            Treasurer
                            • Jul 2011
                            • 2342

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Ivcarlo View Post
                            FANTASTIC i didn't know it.
                            I tried to search myself because i wanted to get there alone without asking... But i don' find where.
                            Please help!
                            Where i can download those?
                            To get to them, as a paid member, go to main forum page then scroll down to the Members Only area about the 4th topic down is The SubCommittee Report
                            Click image for larger version

Name:	SCR_Area.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	98.4 KB
ID:	130705

                            Yes, you can download!
                            If you can cut, drill, saw, hit things and swear a lot, you're well on the way to building a working model sub.

                            Comment

                            • salmon
                              Treasurer
                              • Jul 2011
                              • 2342

                              #15
                              Ivan,
                              Where do you live?

                              Baby and broke, aren't we all in the same boat (except my boy turned 13 so price of toys is more!)

                              This hobby is not cheap, but on a small budget and time, you can build a sub. If you have a secret savings account here is a kit that is complete and you will be assembling it. However, I know many that have it and love it.
                              AKULA II Model Submarine SET - R/C model submarine with radial parting and bayonet lock ring, scale 1/125Hull ready-made and painted flat black! This new model submarine developed by ENGEL offers besi

                              If you want to just start with a hull first..... we have a lot of great vendors that have them, but where you live is important.
                              If you can cut, drill, saw, hit things and swear a lot, you're well on the way to building a working model sub.

                              Comment

                              Working...