Food Fight? - Three bladed US Submarine screws

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • crazy ivan
    SubCommittee Member
    • Feb 2003
    • 659

    #16
    Don, I really like your

    Don, I really like your numbers! Now we're up to 34.7mm. That 35mm Raboesch screw is looking better all the time.
    sigpic
    "There are the assassins, the dealers in death. I am the Avenger!" - Captain Nemo

    -George Protchenko

    Comment

    • boss subfixer
      Junior Member
      • Aug 2004
      • 656

      #17
      HAHAHAHA.
      You know it's possible we

      [color=#000000]HAHAHAHA.
      You know it's possible we are all right with our info. Think about this, you had five shipyards pumping out fleet boats at an alarming rate. My company, Electric Boat, was launching one a month. Maybe (and I'm no expert on props) you also had this same situation with many venders that made the props. Example]



      Edited By Boss subfixer on 1142383283

      Comment

      • JWLaRue
        Managing Editor, SubCommittee Report
        • Aug 1994
        • 4281

        #18
        A very interesting observation!

        I too

        A very interesting observation!

        I too will check some of my other fleetboat plans to see what shows up.

        -Jeff
        Rohr 1.....Los!

        Comment

        • mkeatingss
          Junior Member
          • Nov 2003
          • 244

          #19
          I think that Subfixer has

          I think that Subfixer has hit the answer. There were at least half a dozen prop suppliers, and probably more. Then there were three main yards, building boats. In this environment variations of a couple of inches, in prop diameter, wouldn't be unlikely.
          Because of production/maintenance requirements hub diameter would have to be fixed. As would the hole for the shaft and the mounting bolt holes. The nearest point of the hull, to the prop shaft, would dictate a maximum prop diameter.
          The government requirement would be for a certain amount of power (water moved by the prop) at a given RPM. Blade configuration (dimensions) would be left to the engineers.
          Assuming this was the case, a .2% variation in prop diameter would be well within expected differences.
          Barring a copy, of a government contract for screws, stating a fixed diameter, I'll live with what we have.

          Mike K.

          Comment

          • boss subfixer
            Junior Member
            • Aug 2004
            • 656

            #20
            Mike,
            At the risk of sounding

            Mike,
            At the risk of sounding nit picky, there were five yards building boats. Portsmouth, Electric Boat, Manitowic, Cramp and Mare Island. The latter two did fall off early but were involved none the less.
            Myself I'm going to use 2" props or as close to that I can find and call it good. Still looking for the hub diameter for you.
            BTW, I've already deducted the points for spelling.

            Comment

            • tom dougherty
              Senior Member
              • Jul 2005
              • 1361

              #21
              there were five yards building

              there were five yards building boats. Portsmouth, Electric Boat, Manitowic, Cramp and Mare Island.
              I'd rate Cramp as really questionable in terms of building boats...maybe attempting to build would be a better description. Many of their boats had to be towed elsewhere to be finished. Their completed subs had a terrible reputation. One sank (IIRC, SS-29 Lancetfish) pierside before she even went out on patrol....

              Comment

              • boss subfixer
                Junior Member
                • Aug 2004
                • 656

                #22
                Hi Tom,
                This is very true

                Hi Tom,
                This is very true and thank God things turned out the way they did with Cramp. They were definately over their heads. Who knows what our overall losses would have been if they remained in the game.

                Comment

                Working...
                X